Dear Proposer,

Thank you for your proposal. Our **first** vote on this proposal is **NAY**. Below is the evaluation of our [voting policy v0.3](https://docs.permanence.io/voting_policy/voting_policy_v0.3.html) on this referendum:

```
ROOT
----
8 available members
🟢 0 • 🔴 4 • ⚪️ 0
✓ ≥50.0% required participation met
✘ Ayes <60.0% of all votes
▶ Aye/abstain conditions not met
🔴 NAY
```

Below is a summary of our members' comments:

> Voters unanimously cast a negative ballot on the proposal, all following instructions that had emphasized a contrary stance. Each comment indicated that the nay vote was either directly requested by the proposer or personally affirmed by the voter, leaving no ambiguity in their positions. Their responses demonstrated strict adherence to explicit guidance, and the clear consensus left little room for alternative interpretations. The directive-driven approach underscored a unified decision-making process that reflected the DAO’s predetermined voting policy for this measure, resulting in a decisive and aligned rejection of the proposal.

The full discussion can be found in our [internal voting](https://voting.opensquare.io/space/permanence/proposal/QmdEvmduwWtcXwwfxtPfm8Ur6FioYu7LArk8Z6k3Q6CA2f).

Please feel free to contact us through the links below for further discussion.

Kind regards, Permanence DAO Decentralized Voices Cohort V Delegate 📅 [Book Office Hours](https://cal.com/permanencedao/office-hours) 💬 [Public Telegram](https://t.me/permanencedao) 🌐️ [Web](https://permanence.io) 🐦 [Twitter](https://twitter.com/permanencedao) 🗳️ [Delegate](https://polkadot.subsquare.io/user/15ubZj6T7NUYyQw6j4XBkEMJ2vew5w9kqKEcN1QG7Z1weKDV/votes)

beneficiary

assetKind

amount

validFrom

TimedOut

Submitted

root

whitelisted_caller

wish_for_change

staking_admin

treasurer

lease_admin

fellowship_admin

general_admin

auction_admin

referendum_canceller

referendum_killer

small_tipper

big_tipper

small_spender

medium_spender

big_spender

Origin able to dispatch a whitelisted call.

Origin for signaling that the network wishes for some change

Origin able to cancel slashes and manage minimum commission.

Origin for spending up to 10,000,000 DOT from the treasury as well as generally administering it.

Origin for managing the composition of the fellowship.

Origin able to spend around 250 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend around 1,000 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend around 10,000 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend around 100,000 DOT from the treasury at once.

Origin able to spend up to 1,000,000 DOT from the treasury at once.

[Root] Referendum #1820